Is Misfits Market a Good Deal?
Discounted organic produce and groceries — 'ugly' food that's perfectly good
$30–50/week
Quick Verdict: Is Misfits Market Worth It?
Fair — Deal Score: 7.0/10
| Price | $30–50/week |
| Free Tier | Yes |
| Best For | You want affordable organic produce and don't mind cosmetic imperfections |
| Skip If | You have access to Aldi, Trader Joe's, or farmers markets — similar savings without the subscription |
✓ Pros
- 20-40% cheaper than grocery stores on organic produce
- Reduces food waste — good for the environment
- Now includes meat, seafood, pantry items — not just produce
✗ Cons
- Produce quality is inconsistent — some items are past prime
- Can't choose specific items on cheaper plans
- Delivery areas are limited
Our Analysis
Misfits Market (which absorbed Imperfect Foods in 2023) sells "ugly" and surplus produce alongside a full grocery selection at prices that undercut traditional retailers. There's no required membership — you can order anytime with a $15 minimum. An optional $69/year membership adds free shipping and deeper discounts. Standard shipping is $5.99 plus a $1.99 operations fee per order. The anti-food-waste mission resonates with environmentally conscious shoppers.
The service has evolved significantly from its original produce-box roots. Today's Misfits Market is closer to an online grocery store, with meat, dairy, pantry staples, and snacks alongside the rescued produce. Reddit sentiment has shifted alongside this evolution — early adopters (2020–2021) remember dramatically lower prices, while current users find pricing comparable to regular grocery stores, with savings mainly on organic and specialty items. The produce quality is genuinely hit-or-miss: some weeks you get perfect avocados at 40% off, other weeks the greens arrive wilted.
The honest assessment is that Misfits Market works best as a supplement to your regular grocery shopping, not a replacement. The deals on organic produce, specialty snacks, and private-label items can be excellent, but the inconsistent inventory means you can't rely on finding specific items week to week. Reddit users recommend checking the app weekly for deals rather than setting up a recurring order. If reducing food waste matters to you and you're flexible about what you eat, Misfits Market delivers genuine value. If you need predictable grocery shopping, stick with a traditional store.
Cost Breakdown
No membership required — best value when cherry-picking weekly deals on organic produce and specialty items.
What Real Users Report
The produce is hit or miss but when it hits, the savings are real. Got 3 lbs of organic strawberries for $4 last week.
Prices have gone up a lot since 2021. It used to be dramatically cheaper than the store, now it's about the same unless there's a sale.
This user use it for the specialty stuff — organic snacks, fancy pasta, interesting sauces. The produce they still buy locally.
Worth it if
You want affordable organic produce and don't mind cosmetic imperfections
Skip if
You have access to Aldi, Trader Joe's, or farmers markets — similar savings without the subscription
